top of page

Top Rated Pizza in Pennsylvania: Styles, Toppings and Local Favorites to Try

7 days ago
12 min read

Pennsylvania has one of the most diverse food cultures in the United States. From Philadelphia cheesesteaks and hoagies to Pittsburgh pierogies, Pennsylvania Dutch specialties and distinctive regional pizza traditions, food is deeply connected to the Commonwealth’s communities. For pizza lovers searching for top rated pizza, understanding Pennsylvania’s pizza styles, toppings and local favorites is a great place to begin.


At Luigi’s Pizzarama II in Elkins Park, Pennsylvania, pizza is part of that larger local food tradition. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza, meat-loaded specialty pizza, chicken pizza or a pizza-inspired take on Philadelphia flavors, there are plenty of choices for different tastes.


This guide explores pizza across Pennsylvania, popular styles and toppings, what makes a pizza stand out, and some of the top 10 food items in PA worth knowing about.


best food in Pennsylvania

What Makes Pizza in Pennsylvania Special?


Pennsylvania pizza is not defined by just one recipe.


Different communities across the state have developed their own traditions. Northeast Pennsylvania is particularly well known for Old Forge-style pizza, where a whole pizza may be called a “tray” and individual portions are known as “cuts.” Old Forge pizza typically features a light crust, a somewhat sweeter sauce and a distinctive cheese blend.


Elsewhere in Pennsylvania, diners can find everything from traditional round pizzas and tomato pies to specialty pizzas influenced by Philadelphia’s famous cheesesteak culture.

That diversity is one reason pizza deserves a place in any discussion of popular foods in Pennsylvania.


Why Pennsylvania Is a Great State for Food Lovers


Search for the best food in Pennsylvania, and pizza is only the beginning.

Pennsylvania’s culinary culture reflects generations of immigration, farming, industrial communities and regional traditions. Philadelphia developed foods that became recognized across the country, while Lancaster County became strongly associated with Pennsylvania Dutch cooking. Pittsburgh built its own distinctive food traditions, and Northeast Pennsylvania developed pizza styles unlike those commonly found elsewhere.


Pennsylvania tourism resources highlight foods including:

  • Philly cheesesteaks

  • Pierogies

  • Scrapple

  • Whoopie pies

  • Shoofly pie

  • Pretzels

  • Chocolate

  • Pennsylvania Dutch specialties

  • Regional sandwiches

  • Regional pizza

That variety makes Pennsylvania an interesting destination for anyone who plans trips around food.


What Is Top Rated Pizza?


The phrase top rated pizza can mean different things to different diners.

For one person, the best pizza may be a simple cheese pie with a balanced crust, sauce and cheese combination.

For another, it may be covered with meats, vegetables or specialty toppings.

Rather than focusing only on online star ratings, a great pizza can be evaluated through several qualities.


1. A Well-Made Crust

The crust forms the foundation of the pizza.

Depending on the style, diners may prefer it:

  • Thin and crisp

  • Soft and chewy

  • Light and airy

  • Thick and substantial

  • Slightly crunchy on the outside

There is no single correct pizza crust. What matters is whether it complements the sauce, cheese and toppings.


2. Balanced Sauce

Pizza sauce should contribute flavor without overpowering everything else.

Some people enjoy a sweeter tomato sauce, while others prefer something more savory or herb-forward.

Pennsylvania itself demonstrates how regional preferences can differ. Old Forge-style pizza, for example, is associated with a somewhat sweeter sauce than many conventional pizza styles.


3. The Right Amount of Cheese

Cheese contributes richness, texture and one of pizza’s most recognizable characteristics.

The ideal amount depends on the style. Too little can make a pizza feel incomplete, while excessive cheese can overwhelm the crust and sauce.


4. Quality Toppings

The best specialty pizzas are not simply overloaded with ingredients.

Good toppings should complement one another.

Chicken, meats, vegetables, cheese and sauces should create a cohesive flavor rather than compete for attention.


5. Fresh Preparation

Pizza is at its best when the crust, sauce, cheese and toppings come together fresh from the oven.

That freshness is particularly important when ordering from a neighborhood pizzeria.


Popular Pizza Styles to Try in Pennsylvania


Pennsylvania offers more pizza diversity than many diners realize.

Here are several styles and categories worth exploring.


Traditional Cheese Pizza

Sometimes simplicity wins.

A classic cheese pizza lets the essential pizza components do the work:

Crust + tomato sauce + cheese

Because there are fewer toppings to hide behind, a traditional cheese pizza is also a good way to judge the fundamentals of a pizzeria.


It remains a reliable choice for:

  • Family dinners

  • Office lunches

  • Parties

  • Kids

  • Group orders

  • Casual weekend meals


Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni remains one of the most recognizable American pizza combinations.

Its savory flavor and crisp edges pair naturally with melted cheese and tomato sauce, making it an easy option when ordering for a group.

For people exploring Pennsylvania food through familiar favorites, pepperoni pizza provides an accessible starting point.


Old Forge-Style Pizza: A Pennsylvania Original


One of Pennsylvania’s most interesting contributions to American pizza culture comes from Old Forge in Northeast Pennsylvania.


VisitPA describes Old Forge pizza as a distinctive regional style associated with Italian immigrants who settled around the Scranton area.


Its terminology is even different from conventional pizza language:

  • A whole pizza is often called a tray

  • An individual piece may be called a cut

  • The crust is generally light and crusty with a chewy center

  • The sauce can be sweeter

  • Cheese may include a combination of mozzarella, American and cheddar


This regional tradition demonstrates why there is no single definition of Pennsylvania pizza.

For serious pizza enthusiasts, exploring Old Forge-style pizza can be an important part of understanding famous food in Pennsylvania.


Tomato Pie

Tomato pie is another food closely associated with parts of Pennsylvania and the greater Philadelphia region.

Unlike a conventional pizza where cheese usually dominates the top layer, tomato pie emphasizes tomato sauce.


Different bakeries and pizzerias make it in different ways, but its distinctive appearance and flavor have earned it a place in regional food culture.

Luigi’s Pizzarama II also lists Tomato Pie among its catering offerings in Elkins Park.


Specialty Pizza: More Flavor in Every Slice


Specialty pizzas give pizzerias an opportunity to combine pizza with other familiar flavors.

Instead of choosing each topping individually, diners can select a combination developed around a particular flavor profile.


Popular possibilities include:

  • Meat-focused pizzas

  • Chicken pizzas

  • Vegetable pizzas

  • Cheesesteak-inspired pizzas

  • Buffalo-style pizzas

  • BBQ-style pizzas

These options help turn pizza from a basic meal into something that suits different cravings.


BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ chicken pizza provides an alternative to traditional tomato-sauce combinations.


The savory chicken and barbecue-inspired flavor make it especially appealing for:

  • Game days

  • Weekend meals

  • Parties

  • Casual dinners

  • Groups that want multiple pizza varieties

It is also a good example of how modern pizza can incorporate flavors associated with other American foods.


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Few combinations feel more suited to game day than buffalo-style chicken and pizza.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza takes the flavor people associate with wings and brings it into a shareable pizza format.


That makes it particularly useful for:

  • NFL Sundays

  • Football watch parties

  • Game nights

  • Weekend gatherings

  • Casual group meals

At Luigi’s Pizzarama II in Elkins Park, specialty pizza options allow local diners to go beyond a basic cheese pizza when they want stronger flavors.


Meat Lovers Pizza

For diners who prefer a more substantial specialty pizza, Meat Lovers-style pizza is another popular choice.

The concept is straightforward: create a pizza focused on savory meat toppings rather than vegetables or lighter combinations.


It can be particularly appealing for:

  • Hearty dinners

  • Parties

  • Football nights

  • Friday-night pizza

  • Group orders

If you are ordering several pizzas for a gathering, combining one meat-focused pizza with cheese and vegetable options can also give guests more variety.


Philly Cheesesteak Pizza: Two Pennsylvania Favorites Meet


Few foods have a stronger association with Pennsylvania than the Philadelphia cheesesteak.

VisitPA highlights the cheesesteak as one of Pennsylvania’s signature foods, with Philadelphia particularly associated with the sandwich.


That makes a Philly Cheesesteak Pizza an interesting fusion of two favorites:

Philadelphia-inspired cheesesteak flavor + pizza

For Pennsylvania diners, this type of specialty pizza feels particularly relevant because it connects one of the state’s best-known foods with one of America’s most popular meals.

Luigi’s Pizzarama II offers food inspired by the broader Philadelphia-area pizzeria tradition, making its Elkins Park location a convenient option for local customers looking for familiar regional flavors.


What Are the Most Popular Pizza Toppings?


Pizza preferences vary enormously, but several toppings and combinations continue to appeal to a broad audience.


Cheese

The classic.

A well-made cheese pizza remains one of the easiest options for families and large groups because of its broad appeal.


Pepperoni

Pepperoni adds a salty, savory element without making the pizza overly complicated.


Sausage

Sausage provides a richer, heartier flavor and pairs well with peppers, onions and other vegetables.


Mushrooms

Mushrooms add an earthy flavor and can work with both meat and vegetarian pizzas.


Peppers

Peppers add texture, color and a slightly sweet flavor depending on the variety.


Onions

Onions pair especially well with:

  • Sausage

  • Cheesesteak-inspired pizzas

  • Peppers

  • Mushrooms

  • Meat combinations


Chicken

Chicken gives pizzerias more flexibility because it can be paired with several flavor profiles, including:

  • BBQ

  • Buffalo

  • Cheese

  • Vegetables

  • Specialty sauces


Meat Combinations

For diners seeking something filling, combinations of multiple meat toppings remain a popular specialty pizza direction.


How to Choose the Right Pizza


Choosing pizza sounds simple until you look at a full menu.

Here is an easy way to narrow the options.


For Traditional Pizza Lovers

Choose:

  • Cheese

  • Pepperoni

  • Sausage

  • Mushroom

  • Pepper and onion combinations


For Meat Lovers

Consider:

  • Meat Lovers-style pizza

  • Sausage combinations

  • Pepperoni combinations

  • Cheesesteak-inspired pizza


For Chicken Fans

Try:

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza

  • Other chicken specialty combinations


For Groups

Ordering more than one variety often works better than trying to find a single pizza everyone likes.

For example:

Pizza 1: Cheese

Pizza 2: Meat specialty

Pizza 3: Vegetable or lighter option

Pizza 4: Buffalo Chicken or BBQ Chicken

That gives the table several different flavors.


Top 10 Food Items in PA Every Food Lover Should Know


People searching for the top 10 food items in PA will encounter a mix of regional specialties rather than one uniform statewide cuisine.


Here are 10 foods strongly connected with Pennsylvania food culture or widely enjoyed throughout the state.


1. Philly Cheesesteak

No Pennsylvania food list feels complete without the Philly cheesesteak.

Philadelphia's famous sandwich has become known far beyond Pennsylvania.


2. Pizza

Pizza deserves a place near the top because of Pennsylvania's unusual regional variations as well as the enormous number of traditional neighborhood pizzerias throughout the state.

From Old Forge-style pizza in Northeast Pennsylvania to Philadelphia-area tomato pies and specialty pizzas, Pennsylvania offers considerable variety.


3. Hoagies
The hoagie is deeply associated with the Philadelphia region.

Packed into a long roll with meats, cheese, vegetables and other ingredients, it is another staple of neighborhood pizzerias and sandwich shops.


4. Soft Pretzels

Pennsylvania has an especially strong connection with pretzels.

Lititz is home to the historic Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery, which VisitPA identifies as the country's first commercial pretzel bakery.


5. Pierogies

Pierogies have a particularly strong cultural presence around Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania.

These filled dumplings reflect the influence of Eastern European communities on Pennsylvania's culinary identity.


6. Scrapple

Scrapple is especially associated with Pennsylvania Dutch and rural Pennsylvania food traditions.

Typically sliced and fried, it remains one of the Commonwealth's more distinctive breakfast foods.


7. Shoofly Pie

Shoofly pie is a molasses-based Pennsylvania Dutch dessert closely associated with Lancaster County and surrounding areas.


8. Whoopie Pies

Whoopie pies are another sweet food commonly associated with Pennsylvania Dutch country.

They usually feature two cake-like rounds with a creamy filling between them.


9. Tomato Pie

Tomato pie has strong ties to Philadelphia-area and Pennsylvania Italian-American food traditions.

Its sauce-forward approach distinguishes it from conventional cheese-dominant pizza.


10. Stromboli

A stromboli offers another Italian-American favorite commonly found on Pennsylvania pizzeria menus.

Filled, rolled and baked, it provides a different experience from a traditional pizza while using many familiar ingredients.


Is Pizza One of the Best Foods in Pennsylvania?


For many diners, absolutely.

But there is no objective single best food in Pennsylvania.

What makes Pennsylvania interesting is the range.


Someone visiting Philadelphia may prioritize cheesesteaks, hoagies, tomato pie and pizza.

Travel toward Lancaster County and foods such as scrapple, shoofly pie and whoopie pies become part of the experience.


Head toward Pittsburgh and pierogies become increasingly prominent.

Travel into Northeast Pennsylvania and Old Forge-style pizza deserves attention.


Instead of asking which single food is best, a better question might be:

Which Pennsylvania foods should you try first?

For pizza lovers, regional and neighborhood pizza should certainly be on the list.


Famous Food in Pennsylvania: Why Regional Identity Matters


Food is often tied to place.

Pennsylvania is a particularly good example because different areas developed recognizable specialties.


Philadelphia Area

Known for foods such as:

  • Cheesesteaks

  • Hoagies

  • Soft pretzels

  • Roast pork sandwiches

  • Tomato pie

  • Pizza


Lancaster and Pennsylvania Dutch Country

Known for:

  • Shoofly pie

  • Scrapple

  • Whoopie pies

  • Chow-chow

  • Apple butter

  • Pennsylvania Dutch baked goods


Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania

Known for:

  • Pierogies

  • Hearty sandwiches

  • Eastern European-influenced dishes


Northeast Pennsylvania

Particularly interesting for pizza lovers because of:

  • Old Forge-style pizza

  • Regional cold pizza traditions

  • Unique cheese and sauce combinations

This regional diversity explains why searches for famous food in Pennsylvania produce so many different answers.


Must Try Food in Pennsylvania for Pizza Lovers


If pizza is your main interest, your Pennsylvania food checklist should include more than one pizza experience.


Consider trying:


A Classic Cheese Pizza

Start with the fundamentals.


A Pennsylvania Regional Pizza Style

Old Forge-style pizza offers one of the Commonwealth’s most recognizable regional variations.


Tomato Pie

Try the sauce-forward regional favorite.


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

A strong choice for people who enjoy spicy, game-day flavors.


BBQ Chicken Pizza

Another specialty alternative to conventional tomato-and-cheese combinations.


Meat Lovers Pizza

A hearty choice for diners who favor savory meat toppings.


Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

Especially appropriate when exploring Philadelphia-area food culture.

Together, these show how broad the idea of “pizza” can become.


Popular Foods in Pennsylvania for Parties and Game Day


Pennsylvania food culture is not limited to historical dishes.

Modern gatherings often revolve around foods that are easy to share.

Popular choices include:

  • Pizza

  • Buffalo wings

  • Hoagies

  • Stromboli

  • Chicken fingers

  • Fries

  • Pasta trays

  • Salads

Pizza works particularly well because multiple varieties can be ordered for different preferences.


Luigi’s Pizzarama II’s current catering menu in Elkins Park includes options such as tomato pie, stromboli trays, Buffalo wings, chicken fingers and fries, assorted hoagie trays, assorted wrap trays, baked ziti, lasagna and other hot and cold trays, giving groups options beyond pizza alone.


Pizza for Family Dinners


One reason pizza remains popular is convenience.

For a family dinner, pizza eliminates much of the preparation and cleanup associated with cooking several different meals.

A mixed order might include:

  • One cheese pizza for traditional tastes

  • One specialty pizza for adults

  • Wings or chicken fingers

  • Fries

  • Salad

  • A hoagie or stromboli

This makes it easier to accommodate different preferences at the same table.


famous food in Pennsylvania

Pizza for Football and Game Day


Football and pizza naturally go together because pizza is:

  • Easy to share

  • Easy to portion

  • Available in many varieties

  • Convenient for groups

  • Simple to eat while watching the game

Buffalo Chicken and BBQ Chicken varieties are particularly natural choices for football gatherings because their flavors already have strong associations with casual American game-day food.


Pizza for Parties and Celebrations


When ordering for a larger group, variety generally matters more than ordering only one flavor.

Consider offering a mix such as:

Classic: Cheese

Popular: Pepperoni

Hearty: Meat Lovers

Bold: Buffalo Chicken

Different: Philly Cheesesteak-style

Vegetable option: Vegetable-topped pizza

The right quantity will depend on the number of guests, their appetites and other foods being served.


Where to Find Pizza in Elkins Park, Pennsylvania


For people in the Philadelphia-area community of Elkins Park, Luigi’s Pizzarama II provides a local option for pizza and other pizzeria favorites.


The restaurant is located at:


Customers can explore pizza along with other menu options and place orders through the restaurant.

Luigi’s also serves customers looking for food for:

  • Family dinners

  • Weekend meals

  • Parties

  • Office lunches

  • Game days

  • Casual gatherings

  • Catering occasions


Why Support a Local Pennsylvania Pizzeria?


Pennsylvania's food identity was not created by a single restaurant chain.

It developed through local bakeries, diners, markets, sandwich shops, neighborhood restaurants and pizzerias.


Choosing a neighborhood pizzeria allows customers to participate in that local food culture while enjoying familiar favorites prepared close to home.


For Elkins Park residents, Luigi’s Pizzarama II brings together pizza and other foods associated with the broader Philadelphia-area dining tradition.


FAQs


What is the most famous food in Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania is associated with several famous foods rather than one single dish. The Philadelphia cheesesteak is among the best known nationally, while pierogies, Pennsylvania Dutch dishes, soft pretzels, tomato pie and regional pizza styles also play important roles in the state's food culture.


What is considered top rated pizza?

Top rated pizza generally combines a well-prepared crust, balanced sauce, cheese, quality toppings and consistent preparation. Personal preference also matters, so the “best” pizza style can vary considerably from one diner to another.


Does Pennsylvania have its own pizza style?

Yes. Old Forge-style pizza from Northeast Pennsylvania is one of the state's best-known regional pizza traditions. A whole pizza may be called a tray and individual portions are known as cuts.


What foods should tourists try in Pennsylvania?

Some must try food in Pennsylvania includes cheesesteaks, pizza, hoagies, soft pretzels, pierogies, scrapple, shoofly pie, whoopie pies and tomato pie.


Is Philadelphia known for pizza?

Philadelphia and its surrounding communities have a strong pizza and Italian-American food culture. The region is also particularly well known for cheesesteaks, hoagies, tomato pie and soft pretzels.


What pizza toppings are most popular?

Cheese and pepperoni remain classic choices, while sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, chicken and meat combinations are common options. Specialty pizzas such as Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Chicken and Meat Lovers provide stronger flavor combinations.


What pizza is good for game day?

Buffalo Chicken Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, pepperoni pizza and Meat Lovers-style pizzas are all suitable options for football parties and other game-day gatherings.


What are the top 10 food items in PA?

A useful Pennsylvania food bucket list includes Philly cheesesteaks, pizza, hoagies, soft pretzels, pierogies, scrapple, shoofly pie, whoopie pies, tomato pie and stromboli.


Where can I get pizza in Elkins Park, PA?

Luigi’s Pizzarama II is located at 417 Township Line Road, Elkins Park, PA 19027, serving pizza and other pizzeria favorites to the local community.


Discover Pennsylvania One Pizza at a Time


From Philadelphia-inspired flavors to the unique pizza traditions of Northeast Pennsylvania, the Commonwealth offers plenty for pizza lovers to explore. Pizza belongs alongside cheesesteaks, hoagies, pierogies, soft pretzels and Pennsylvania Dutch specialties when talking about popular foods in Pennsylvania.


Whether you are researching the best food in Pennsylvania, building a list of must try food in Pennsylvania, looking for top rated pizza, or simply deciding what to order for dinner, exploring different pizza styles and toppings is an excellent place to start.


For pizza lovers around Elkins Park, Luigi’s Pizzarama II offers a local way to enjoy pizza and other familiar Pennsylvania-area pizzeria favorites for family meals, gatherings, game days and everyday cravings.



Comments


  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Join Our Mailing List

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page